WorkLifePsych WorkLifePsych
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Coaching
    • Training
    • Development
  • Solutions
    • Wellbeing
      • Wellbeing Courses
      • Psychological Flexibility
    • Productivity
      • Productivity Courses
    • Effectiveness
      • Effectiveness Courses
    • Community Plus
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Contact
WorkLifePsych WorkLifePsych
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Coaching
    • Training
    • Development
  • Solutions
    • Wellbeing
      • Wellbeing Courses
      • Psychological Flexibility
    • Productivity
      • Productivity Courses
    • Effectiveness
      • Effectiveness Courses
    • Community Plus
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Contact
Jun 17

A waste of good ink…

  • June 17, 2013
  • Richard MacKinnon
  • 2 Comments
  • Personality
  • Assessment, BBC, Graphology, Handwriting Analysis, Pseudo-Science

File this under “Sad but true”: organisations still use the discredited pseudo-science of graphology to select employees. I recently came across an article on BBC News about its continued use in France.

Wait: haven’t we been through this before? Yes. I wrote about it back in 2010, when the Telegraph discussed the handwriting of UK politicians in the run up to the general election.

Interestingly, although graphologists claim to have lots of work, few organisations own up to using it as a methodology. Perhaps they’re embarrassed?

The last independent study was in 1991, and it found that a massive 91% of public and private organisations in France were then making use of handwriting analysis.

Scary.

Graphologists’ logic is circular. They point to its complexity and its simultaneous simplicity. They argue that its success can’t be measured using conventional means (a little like those advocating homeopathy and similar approaches) but point to their clients’ satisfaction as the criterion for success.

“And just because we cannot measure its success rate using mathematics or statistics – that doesn’t mean it is not a valid tool. In all our client studies, there is an extremely high satisfaction coefficient. People use it because it works.”

On the face of it, it sounds like an appealing concept. That our personality is writ large (pun intended) by our handwriting. Surely an analysis of this – by trained professionals, of course – will provide useful insight into our inner world. Handwriting is, after all, quite personal and distinct.

The research evidence is overwhelming negative when it comes to the validity of graphology as a tool for selecting employees. It doesn’t assess personality and cannot predict fit for role or performance in role.

You might as well consult a medium or astrologer.

But, please…don’t!

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • E-Mail

About The Author

The Founder and Managing Director of WorkLifePsych, Richard is a Chartered Psychologist and Coach. He's passionate about helping people be their best selves at work and effectively managing their wellbeing and productivity in a proactive and sustainable way.

Related Posts

2 Comments

  1. Mark Abrahams
    June 18, 2013 at 8:20 am · Reply

    Hi Richard,

    I saw this article back in April – and frustratingly being an online BBC News Magazine article one cannot comment on it, so had to resort to FB. It is a shame that in this scientific age some smart and/or large businesses still do not review the available evidence.

    • WorkLifePsych
      June 18, 2013 at 4:28 pm · Reply

      Hi Mark,

      Thanks for visiting! Indeed, frustrating that this kind of thing still goes on. It’s amazing what is accepted as “fact” in the world of psychology.

Leave a reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Values: It’s about action
  • Coaching: it won’t make you happy!
  • Protecting yourself against Derailment
  • Derailment: How our strengths can work against us
  • Understanding career derailment

Categories

  • Assessment
  • Careers
  • Coaching
  • Conferences & Events
  • CyberPsychology
  • Development
  • Diversity
  • Effectiveness
  • Ethics
  • Events
  • Flexible Working
  • Intentional Living
  • News
  • Organisational Culture
  • Personal Development
  • Personality
  • Podcast
  • Positive Psychology
  • Productivity
  • Psychological flexibility
  • Technology
  • Training
  • Uncategorized
  • Webinars
  • Wellbeing
  • Work-Life Balance

We are a team of accredited and experienced workplace psychologists who are passionate about the practical application of psychology in the workplace. We focus on the intersection of wellbeing, productivity and professional effectiveness. Our mission is to help people move from merely surviving work to thriving at work.

What We Do

  • Coaching
  • Development
  • Training

Contact Us:

+44 (0)20 4517 3300
info@worklifepsych.com

Recent blog posts

  • Values: It’s about action
  • Coaching: it won’t make you happy!
  • Protecting yourself against Derailment

Search

© WorkLifePsych Ltd 2018 | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy. Website by: Code23